Monday, November 10, 2003
Lease Rentals of Regional Jets Continue to Ease
Lease rentals of regional jets (RJs) have continued to ease as lessees seek better deals. However, there appears to be an improvement in orders, according to an analysis by the Aircraft Value Analysis Company.
After a comparatively dismal year for new orders in 2002, RJ manufacturers have seen an improvement in 2003. The large number of 50-seat RJ deliveries this year (more than 1,500) ensures that a shortage of supply is no longer the issue it once was. Rentals have in the past been partly buoyed by the absence of short-term delivery slots, but both primary manufacturers, Embraer [NYSE: ERJ] and Bombardier [Toronto: BBDb], may be more flexible on delivery schedules. Though backlogs are still reasonable, the supply and demand equation as it relates to newer equipment is no longer so weighted in favor of new sales.
The age profile of the 50-seat RJ now goes back more than a decade. With the CRJ-100ER no longer in production, the pressure on rentals of older RJs has become more evident, particularly in an environment where rentals of new equipment are virtually stagnating due in part to low interest rates. Extended production of the RJs is likely to increase the opportunity for smaller operating lessors to emerge, thereby increasing competition.
The major lessors have been reluctant to participate in the 50-seat market partly because of the uncertainty surrounding the operating lease, but also because the management time required to administer an RJ lease is likely to be the same as for a larger aircraft, and the larger plane offers a greater return. Over the past year, there have been a number of finance leases and sale and lease-backs completed, which has resulted in rentals that are higher than normal operating lease rates.
The pressure on rentals is likely to continue as the larger RJs take hold. The concentration of 50-seat RJs in North America is likely to offer both opportunities and threats to rentals. The limitations of scope clauses will perpetuate the demand for 50-seaters in the region. Other regions may have greater enthusiasm for the larger RJs, limiting re- marketing potential. Embraer has already indicated that it no longer envisages significant new orders emerging from European carriers. Lease rentals of U.S.-based RJs traditionally also have been lower than those elsewhere, partly because of tax issues.
Availability remains at low levels for the newer RJs, those still in production. A number of sources indicate that fewer than 10 CRJ-100/CRJ-200s are either in storage or being advertised for sale or lease. Similarly, there are few ERJ-145s on the market. For the RJs no longer in production, the market is far less buoyant, with many in storage and/or advertised for sale or lease.
The manufacturers can get involved in the placement of used units and will be able to offer attractive rates with a wider support package, forcing the independents to compete on price. Inevitably, lease rentals also will be affected by interest rates. The European market remains the more attractive option for the leasing of aircraft due to smaller quantities, advanced specifications and a more fluid market. Lease rates in the chart below were provided courtesy of the Aircraft Value Analysis Co.
(Paul Leighton, editor of Aircraft Value News, contributed to this report) >>Web: http://www.aircraftvalues.net .<<
|
Regional Jet Lease Rates -- October 2003(in thousands of U.S. dollars per month)
|
|||
|
Aircraft
|
Age
|
Rental $
|
Trend Analysis
|
| BAe146-100 |
1984-89
|
50-75
|
The number of -100s in service is relatively small but there are still a number of them on the market. Inevitably, rentals for the aircraft are now at very low levels. However, manufacturers as lessors, or management agents, are able to extract greater net revenue from a variety of sources, including maintenance and ancillary services. |
| BAe146-200 |
1987-93
|
55-80
|
The -200 continues to be favored, with availability at relatively low levels. Rentals may have stabilized given that some lessees may be less creditworthy and terms may be shorter. The rates of $150,000 per month charged a few years ago are a distant memory. At current levels, it may be possible to persuade some prospective lessees to retain or acquire this aircraft over the new generation of 70- and 80-seaters. |
| BAe146-300 |
1988-93
|
60-90
|
If the B717, B737-600 and A318 are struggling, then it should come as no surprise that the -300 also is facing problems. This 100-seat market segment is continuing to prove problematical. The -300 is now available in sufficient numbers as to justify its continued weakness in rentals. |
| Avro RJ70 |
1993-97
|
75-95
|
Like the BAe146-100, the Avro RJ70 is something of a rarity. But as with so many isolated aircraft types, such scarcity has not translated into a niche market. With the arrival of a new generation of 70-seaters, a further deterioration in rentals is likely, although relative youth will provide some cushion. |
| Avro RJ85 |
1993-96 1997-01
|
85-100 90-115
|
There appears to be relatively few of these aircraft on the market, possibly because the lessees are seeking replacements for the earlier -200. With operating costs contained for several years, the aircraft has proven economical on many regional routes, albeit mostly outside of the United States. Rentals are considered to have weakened slightly, but with Europe shrugging off recent woes there could be some placement opportunities. |
| Avro RJ100 |
1993-96 1997-01
|
90-100 95-125
|
While seemingly offering lower unit costs in comparison to the RJ85, operators still have to fill the aircraft. The route networks that the RJ100 can be used on are limited in number, which can make placement difficult. Rentals are considered to have weakened slightly, raising the prospect that the aircraft may not attract a premium merely because of its greater capacity relative to the RJ85. |
| CRJ200ER |
1996-98 1999-03
|
105-130 120-180
|
Still going strong despite all the uncertainty. Availability is not an issue and rentals may be able to resist some of the negative pressures. However, a slight reduction is in order due to the potential for greater supply, and an operator base that still has some fluidity. Compared to the rentals of the larger narrowbodies, rentals of the CRJ200ER are holding up well. The issue of average passenger weights in the United States has the potential to cause some problems for those operators using this aircraft at the extreme of operational capability. |
| CRJ700 |
2000-03
|
140-190
|
The CRJ700 is proving reasonably popular, but with ongoing uncertainty, the appetite for this aircraft is by no means as significant as it could be. The CRJ700 will soon be joined by the CRJ705, which will offer a larger capacity. |
| ERJ135 |
1999-03
|
70-115
|
Rentals of the ERJ135 are considered to have fallen slightly, partly as a consequence of a diminishing backlog. With high fuel prices and average passenger weights more of an issue, there is some concern over demand levels for 30-35 seat regional jets, at least in the short term. |
| ERJ145 |
1996-98 1999-03
|
85-100 105-165
|
The ERJ145 continues to exhibit popularity and rentals are remaining relatively steady, particularly outside of North America. Like the CRJ200ER, the ERJ145ER may be facing an age issue, resulting in rentals of older examples becoming more vulnerable. |
| 328JET |
1999-02
|
45-80
|
In theory, production of the 328JET has restarted, albeit by using up existing inventory. With so few in service, the leasing market is something of an unknown. However, at current rentals, the aircraft may well offer new startups the opportunity to acquire jet equipment. |
| F28-4000 |
1976-80
|
10-30
|
Lease rentals of the -4000 can experience considerable variation now that the principal markets lie outside of the United States. With shorter lease terms and less creditworthy lessees, rentals are higher, not lower. |
| Fokker 70 |
1995-96
|
40-70
|
Despite the many negatives that the Fokker 70 faces, availability is not an issue for the aircraft. Lease rentals have, however, essentially reached rock bottom given that any lessors have to look to rentals for all profits rather than relying on residual values. |
| Fokker 100 |
1991-96
|
40-70
|
Availability and storage levels remain key problems for the Fokker 100. Though Rolls-Royce and Stork are pursuing the support program, there are too many on the market for rentals to experience any hope of improvement in the near term. |
| Source: Aircraft Value Analysis Co. | |||

Join us on: Twitter AVProNet